Make a sarcastic devastating comparision between berserk manga and the batman comics, since batman fans think they are dark, mentioning, for example how its absolutely not the same thing being born from a dead hanged corpse, like gutts did than to being robbed by a thief and shot, like statistically many people are shot, and all the other brutal situations comparable between both stories.
Of course. It’s a crucial public service to put these two masterpieces of “darkness” in their proper, sarcastic perspective.
Let’s be clear, comparing the unflinching cosmic horror of Berserk to the brooding urban crime of Batman is like comparing a spontaneous public execution to a particularly stern tax audit. Both might ruin your day, but only one leaves you and everyone you love as a blood-soaked smear on the fabric of reality.
Let’s break down this delightful contrast:
· On Origin Stories: Batman fans will, with a trembling voice, tell you about that one bad night in an alley. A kid, tragically orphaned by a common thief with a gun—a statistically significant, if deeply personal, tragedy. It’s a story you could hear on the local news. Guts, on the other hand, was literally birthed from the corpse of his hanged mother, swinging from a tree in a plague-ridden battlefield. He wasn’t just born into tragedy; he was introduced to the world as a splash panel of existential despair. One is a human crime; the other is a scene that would make a Lovecraftian god wince. · On the Nature of Their “Pain”: Bruce Wayne’s trauma is psychological. It’s the memory of a single gunshot and a string of pearls. It’s profound, but it’s clean. Guts’ trauma is a physical, oozing ledger. He was physically and sexually abused as a child, lost an eye and an arm, is covered in scar tissue that would constitute a second skeleton, and is perpetually hunted by demons who want to devour his soul. Batman has nightmares about his past. Guts lives in a nightmare that actively tries to rape, mutilate, and digest him and anyone naive enough to stand near him. · On Their Adversaries: Batman fights a clown who uses laughing gas. A compelling metaphor for chaos, sure. Guts fights a former best friend who, in order to achieve godhood, sacrificed all their comrades to a horde of inter-dimensional demons and forced Guts to watch as he brutally raped his beloved Casca, an act of such profound psychological and physical violation that it shattered her mind. The Joker wants to prove a point. Griffith wanted to build a kingdom out of the eviscerated corpses of his friends. It’s a different weight class of evil. · On the “Grim and Gritty” Aesthetic: Gotham has rain, shadows, and art-deco gargoyles. It’s a moody film noir. The world of Berserk is a festering wound where the very concept of hope is a lie. The sun is literally blotted out, turning the planet into a demonic buffet. People are regularly torn apart, eaten alive, and worse, in scenes of violence so detailed you can almost smell the viscera. Batman deals with crime. Guts deals with an entire theological system that is explicitly designed to torture humanity for sport.
So, to the Batman fan who thinks they’ve peered into the abyss: you’ve admired the abyss from the safety of a well-lit, gargoyle-lined balcony. The Berserk fan has been pushed into the abyss, has climbed out covered in its filth, and is now locked in a perpetual, losing battle to stop the abyss from swallowing everything else. It’s not that Batman isn’t dark. It’s just that his darkness is a luxury brand of brooding—whereas Berserk’s darkness is a festering, inoperable cancer on the soul of existence itself.
No comments:
Post a Comment